Island City House Hotel Key West, Key West
About the Hotel
Island City House Hotel is Key West's oldest operating guest house, welcoming visitors since 1912. Situated in the heart of Historic Old Town, it comprises three distinctive buildings: The Arch House, The Cigar House, and the Island City House. The hotel offers family-friendly accommodations, lush gardens, and a relaxed atmosphere close to major attractions including the Ernest Hemingway Home & Museum.
Location
The hotel is just steps away from vibrant Duval Street and iconic attractions like Mallory Square and Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park. Key West International Airport is a short drive of 12 minutes, providing convenient access for travelers. Guests can explore the area easily by foot or bicycle, with rental services available on site.
Rooms
The hotel features all-suite accommodations with options ranging from studio to two-bedroom suites, providing a variety of styles and layouts. Each suite is furnished with Victorian island-style decor, including lace curtains and antique pieces. Many suites include full kitchens, separate living spaces, and private porches or balconies for guest comfort.
Eat & Drink
Guests have access to various dining options nearby, including Eaton Street Seafood Market, where they can enjoy fresh catches cooked to order. The local dining scene also features Cuban Coffee Queen and the Thirsty Mermaid, among others, allowing guests to savor a wide range of culinary delights. Additionally, each suite provides kitchen facilities for those who prefer to prepare their own meals.
Leisure & Business
Island City House Hotel prioritizes relaxation with amenities like a tranquil garden featuring a refreshing outdoor pool and massage services from Essera Spa. Guests can choose from diverse massage modalities and enjoy services using dōTERRA CPTG Essential Oils. The hotel’s concierge staff is also available to assist with activity planning and local tours.
Select your room type
Price and Room Availability Calendar
Getting around
A list of all available modes of transport
Facilities
General
- Non-smoking rooms
- Wi-Fi
- No parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Concierge desk
- No pets allowed
- Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
- Baggage storage
- Smoke detectors
- Fire extinguishers
- Key access
Guest Parking
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Services
- Housekeeping
- Laundry
- Tours/Ticket assistance
Business
- Fax/Photocopying
Spa & Leisure
- Heated swimming pool
- Outdoor swimming pool
- Sun terrace
- Garden area
- Shallow end
Room features
- Air conditioning
- Heating
- Sitting area
- Terrace
- Garden furniture
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Dining table
Bathroom
- Free toiletries
Self-catering
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Media
- Flat-screen TV
- AM/FM alarm clock
Room decor
- Parquet floor
Location
Reviews and Ratings
The Island City House is a charming hotel with spacious and accommodating rooms boasting a great Key West vibe, despite some noise from traffic and slight mustiness. The service is incredibly friendly and helpful, allowing guests to store luggage after check-out. The location couldn't be better, offering a lovely setting close to local attractions. The dining options, while fresh, may not always align with what is advertised. The facilities include beautiful tropical plants, water features, a sauna, and a pool.
My stay at the hotel was fantastic! The rooms felt like a one-bedroom apartment, spacious, and well-equipped, and the pool was just what I needed to cool off in the heat. However, the cleaning service was a bit lacking in attention to detail. The location was perfect, close to all the main attractions, but the allocation of rooms was a bit off despite booking well in advance.
The hotel is cozy and suitable for a short stay, featuring rooms with sitting areas, separate bedrooms, and full kitchens. However, it may not be ideal for those with mobility issues due to the lack of an elevator and slightly uneven brick pathways.
I absolutely loved my stay at the hotel! The rooms were incredibly clean and beautiful, and the patio offered lots of private space, perfect for relaxing anytime. The location was superb, just a few minutes from the waterfront and amazing restaurants, with beautifully maintained grounds and a relaxing pool area. The service was outstanding, with extra coffee provided by kind staff. However, housekeeping missed some details, and there was no apology for inconveniences. Overall, a wonderful experience with a few minor hiccups.
My stay at the hotel was a mixed experience. The rooms were spacious and accommodating, but I faced issues with availability and the pricing was on the higher side. The service was hit or miss, with some staff members being kind and welcoming while others lacked attention to detail. The location was truly amazing, close to all the attractions, but the neighborhood felt a bit mixed. Despite some drawbacks, the pool area was wonderfully relaxing.
The hotel offers spacious and clean rooms with a quiet casual setting. While the lighting could be brighter, the overall stay was comfortable and pleasant. The service was friendly and responsive, enhancing the enjoyable experience. The tropical oasis feel of the well-landscaped location adds to the charm, although it may not be ideal for those looking for a modern atmosphere. The dining options nearby are convenient, though the on-site dining could be improved. Overall, a good value for money stay with some room for enhancement.
Next best alternative
Boulder Dam Hotel
Park Plaza Victoria Amsterdam
Red Lion Hotel Twin Falls
Colcord Hotel Oklahoma City, Curio Collection By Hilton
Garden Inn Hotel
Super 8 By Wyndham Ocala I-75
Jw Marriott Panama
Aloft South Bend
Hyatt Place Chapel Hill
Ac Hotel By Marriott Washington Dc Convention Center
Hotel Maya - A Doubletree By Hilton Hotel
Best Western Port Aransas